How to Sell Your Comic Book Collection for High Value

How to Sell Your Comic Book Collection for High Value

Remember when Tony Stark broke onto the silver screen in 2008? People took a real shine to Ol’ Shellhead, with Iron Man comics sales rising 22% with about 47,900 copies per month. That's after seven straight years of decline.

Besides being a testament to Iron Man’s huge fan base, this shows how superhero movies affect comic book sales. Ever since our favorite characters moved from page to (movie) stage, graded comic books have dramatically increased in value. And not just the emotional kind.

So, if you’re an avid collector looking to sell graded comic books, you’re in luck. With more superhero films in the offing, there’s no time like now to cash in on your collection. In fact, Amazing Fantasy #15 recently sold for an earth-shattering $3.6 million

Six Tips to Sell Graded Comic Books

However, the value of graded comic books varies based on several factors. It helps to do your homework when you’re ready to take the leap. This way, you’ll know how to maximize their price. 

Seems complicated? It isn’t. Let’s look at a few tips on how to sell graded comic books and get the most bang for your buck.

  1.     Get them Graded, Stat

There’s a reason why we’re talking about selling graded comic books. Graded comics have significantly more value than their non-graded counterparts, primarily because they’ve been authenticated by a reputable grading company. Basically, this means someone has taken the time to comb through the comic, identify its perks/flaws, and assign it an appropriate grade.

Most collectors are much more willing to pay top dollar for high-quality graded comic books, provided they are vetted by the CGC or CBCS. It's a way of ensuring they’re getting their money’s worth.

  1.     Choose Issues and Titles Carefully 

The titles in your collection and the year they were released play a vital role in determining the value of graded comic books. Certain old comics are in high demand, like Detective Comics #27, which sold for a whopping $1.5 million in 2020. On the other hand, some are rare, and some won’t cost more than when you first bought them. 

While there’s no solid way to predict when a comic book title will find favor with the masses, here are a few things you should look for when picking issues:

  • First appearances
  • Origin stories
  • Special events
  • Unique outfits
  • Figure/writer/illustrator
  • Signature
  1.     Keep Them in Good Condition

Preserving your comic books is a no-brainer. Even if they are graded and slabbed, you need to look after them.

Always store your comics in a cool, dry place. And, if you’re planning to display graded comic books, it’s best to keep them away from direct sunlight.

For non-graded comic books, be careful not to stack them. The pressure from the top books can damage the ones at the bottom of the pile. Instead, place them in clear plastic bags and hoist them upright. 

Many veteran collectors also advise against storing comic books on the floor of garages and basements, especially if it’s prone to flooding. Put the boxes on milk crates or wooden pallets to be on the safe side. 

  1.     Know the Best Place to Sell

It can be hard to figure out where to sell your comics. After all, you don’t want to downplay the value of graded comic books

First, try your local comic book store and see if they are interested in your graded comic books. You may get a good offer if the dealer wants a particular issue for themselves or a customer.

If you want to ensure your graded comic book collection goes to a good home, consider setting up a stall at a convention. Otherwise, you can also use online auction sites. Be sure to weigh all your options carefully before making a decision.

  1.     Sell Complete Storylines at the Same Time 

Few things are as satisfying as finding a complete comic run in one place. If a storyline has eight or nine parts, selling them together might be in your best interest. Buyers are more likely to shell out for full sets, as it saves them the trouble of locating missing entries down the line.

Not to mention, owning a complete run casts you as a serious collector. It’s a great way to impress people and get them to explore other items in your graded comic book collection.

  1.     Wait for the Perfect Opportunity

We’ve already mentioned how popular media affects comic book sales. Keep an eye on upcoming release schedules and sell graded comic books related to those characters accordingly.

Hero and villain debuts generally create a ton of buzz, and The Avengers is a great example of this. Even though Black Panther had appeared in comic book pages decades before his first film, the character exploded in popularity after The Avengers: Civil War. If you were to sell a copy of Fantastic Four #52 (T’Challa’s first appearance) in 2016, you’d likely make good money off it.

A lot of independent comics are being adapted for the screen. We suggest you wait till they air before selling those editions. 


Check Out Wicked Monkey’s Vast Range of Graded Comic Books

Parting with a prized comic collection is tough. But the least you can do is trade it for good money. Hopefully, this post has given you some insight into how to sell your graded comic book collection for high value.

Once you’re ready to start collecting again, just head on over to Wicked Monkey’s graded comic books inventory. We have a wide selection of graded comics from multiple series, authors, and illustrators, so you’re sure to be spoiled for choice. Don’t believe us? Contact us or check out our online inventory today!

Leave a comment. You do you.

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published