Which One is Better - CGC or CBCS for Comic Books Grading?
For any rookie collector, there will come a time when they must think about getting their comic books graded. Slabbing comics is a great way to preserve them in the long run. Plus, graded comic books sell for a lot more than non-graded (raw) copies, so it’s a win-win!
Once you decide on comic book grading, you’ll have to pick a reputable third-party organization to get the job done. In this regard, you have two options to choose from: CGC and CBCS.
For the longest time, comic book enthusiasts swore by CGC. Even today, several buyers and comic investors regard it as an indisputable champion in the grading industry.
That said, CBCS is quickly rising to the gold standard set by its predecessor.
In case you’re having trouble selecting a grading services company, knowing about the pros and cons of each may help. Let’s dive in.
- What is CGC Comic Books Grading?
The fact that the Certified Guaranty Company (CGC) has been around for nearly two decades should tell you a lot about its reputation. Since its inception in 2000, the company has graded nearly 6 million collectibles. Even today, it is the go-to comic books grading service for multiple buyers and investors.
- The Pros and Cons of CGC Comic Books Grading
When it comes to grading collectible comic books, CGC is hard to beat. Here are a few reasons why CGC grading is worth the money.
A) Protective Casing
You need not worry about dropping CGC graded comic books, because they come in a transparent protective case! The case takes all the damage, leaving the comic inside unharmed. This preserves your CGC graded comic books for longer.
B) Easy Evaluation
Disaster can strike any time, and your home insurer will likely not pay for any damage to your expensive graded comic books collection. That is, unless they’ve been graded by CGC. In this scenario, the insurance adjuster can easily assess the loss and write you a check for it.
You can also easily sell your CGC graded comic books for a significant amount, if they are already graded.
That said, CGC is not entirely without fault. Let’s look at a few of its downsides.
C) Paid Membership
To get your comics graded by the CGC, you must either submit them at a convention, contact an authorized comics dealer, or become a member. Associate membership costs about $25 as of 2021. Although this may not sound much, it is money down the drain if you don’t have a lot of comics to grade.
CGC is largely recognized as a veteran in the grading market. Over two decades, they’ve improved their processes significantly. Although they’re almost always on the money with their grades, some CGC graded comic books may have a few inconsistencies.
- What is CBCS Comic Books Grading?
Founded by CGC’s original primary grader Steve Borock, the Comic Book Certification Service (CBCS) has quickly earned a top spot in the grading industry: despite being around for a substantially shorter period. CBCS’s grading methods are quite similar to CGC’s (hard case and everything!), save a few key aspects.
- CBCS’s fees are slightly lower than CGC
- Unlike CGC, you don’t need a membership to submit your comics through CBCS’s website.
- The Pros and Cons of CBCS Comic Books Grading
Needless to say, CBCS offers a range of advantages to collectors, a few of which are as follows.
A) Signature Verification Services
Ever since CBCS partnered with CSA Comics, they’ve brought new hope to collectors looking to get their signed copies graded. In case you have an autographed comic book, but no way to authenticate it, CBCS may be the way to go.
B) Free Grader Notes
Did you know that CBCS graded comic books come with grader notes? These notes tell you why and how your comic got its grade. And the best part is, it’s free of charge!
Again, comic books grading with CBCS is not all roses. Let’s look at a few cons of the company.
C) Lower Selling Prices
CBCS graded comic books usually have lower resale values than comparable CGC counterparts. There’s no formal reason for this, although most collectors naturally gravitate towards CGC graded comic books.
D) Increased Turnaround Times
Unless you’re willing to shell out for the fast-track service, you may have to wait 4-6 weeks to get your CBCS graded comic books.
- Should You Choose CGC or CBCS to Grade Your Comic Books
As you see, both CGC and CBCS have their pros and cons. In the end, it all boils down to personal preference. While their prices, labels, and turnaround times for graded comic books may differ, there’s no denying that both companies offer excellent products and services. Just be sure to choose the one that suits your style and pocket!
Hopefully, this post has given you some insight into the two leading comic book companies out there. Remember, there are no wrong answers, so you can pick whichever service works best for you. Your comfort comes first!